🔗 Share this article

One of the most recognizable pictures from the 20th century shows an unclothed girl, her limbs extended, her expression contorted in terror, her body burned and peeling. She is fleeing toward the photographer as fleeing a napalm attack in the Vietnam War. Beside her, youngsters also run away from the bombed community of Trảng Bàng, against a background featuring thick fumes and military personnel.

This Worldwide Effect of an Powerful Picture

Within hours the publication in June 1972, this image—formally called "Napalm Girl"—became a traditional sensation. Viewed and analyzed globally, it is widely attributed with energizing worldwide views critical of the US war in Southeast Asia. A prominent thinker later commented how the horrifically unforgettable photograph featuring the young the girl in distress possibly was more effective to increase popular disgust against the war compared to a hundred hours of shown violence. A legendary British documentarian who reported on the conflict called it the most powerful photo from what would later be called the media war. One more experienced photojournalist remarked how the picture represents simply put, one of the most important photographs in history, specifically of that era.

A Decades-Long Attribution and a Recent Assertion

For over five decades, the photograph was credited to the work of Huynh Cong “Nick” Út, a then-21-year-old local photographer on assignment for an international outlet at the time. Yet a controversial new film released by a global network claims that the well-known image—widely regarded as the apex of photojournalism—may have been captured by another person present that day in Trảng Bàng.

According to the investigation, "Napalm Girl" was in fact taken by a stringer, who provided his work to the news agency. The claim, along with the documentary's following investigation, stems from a former editor Carl Robinson, who alleges that a powerful editor directed the staff to alter the photograph's attribution from the original photographer to Nick Út, the sole employed photographer on site that day.

The Quest to find the Truth

The former editor, advanced in years, contacted one of the journalists recently, requesting help in finding the unknown photographer. He expressed that, if he was still living, he hoped to give an acknowledgment. The journalist thought of the freelance stringers he knew—comparing them to modern freelancers, just as Vietnamese freelancers at the time, are routinely overlooked. Their work is often challenged, and they work amid more challenging conditions. They are not insured, no retirement plans, minimal assistance, they often don’t have adequate tools, and they are highly exposed as they capture images in familiar settings.

The investigator wondered: “What must it feel like to be the individual who took this iconic picture, if indeed he was not the author?” As a photographer, he imagined, it must be extraordinarily painful. As a student of war photography, especially the celebrated documentation from that war, it would be reputation-threatening, possibly career-damaging. The respected history of "Napalm Girl" among the diaspora is such that the creator with a background fled in that period was hesitant to take on the project. He expressed, I hesitated to disrupt this long-held narrative that Nick had taken the image. And I didn’t want to change the status quo of a community that consistently respected this accomplishment.”

The Search Progresses

But the two the investigator and the director concluded: it was necessary posing the inquiry. “If journalists must hold others responsible,” remarked the investigator, we must be able to ask difficult questions within our profession.”

The film follows the investigators in their pursuit of their inquiry, from eyewitness interviews, to requests in today's the city, to archival research from related materials taken that day. Their search eventually yield a candidate: a driver, employed by NBC that day who sometimes provided images to the press as a freelancer. As shown, a moved Nghệ, currently elderly based in the US, attests that he sold the photograph to the news organization for $20 and a copy, yet remained troubled by the lack of credit for years.

This Reaction Followed by Further Analysis

Nghệ appears throughout the documentary, thoughtful and reflective, however, his claim turned out to be controversial within the world of war photography. {Days before|Shortly prior to